Articles Service
Research article
Optimization of Ultrasound-Assisted Pretreatment for Accelerating Rehydration of Adzuki Bean (Vigna angularis)
1Department of Food Science and Biotechnology, Gachon University, Seongnam 13120, Republic of Korea
2Smart Food Manufacturing Project Group, Korea Food Research Institute, Wanju 55365, Republic of Korea.
3Research and Development Dept., B.E.T., Busan 48119, Republic of Korea
4Seoul International School, Seongnam 13113, Republic of Korea
5Department of Environmental Horticulture, University of Seoul, Seoul 02504, Republic of Korea
J. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 2024; 34(4): 846-853
Published April 28, 2024 https://doi.org/10.4014/jmb.2401.01004
Copyright © The Korean Society for Microbiology and Biotechnology.
Abstract
Keywords
Graphical Abstract
Introduction
The adzuki bean (
Beans, including adzuki beans are important suppliers of plant-based proteins and functional substances but require hydration for processes such as germination and fermentation [8]. In the seed coat of beans are the hilum, a scar marking the former attachment of the bean to the plant stalk, and the micropyle, a microscopic hole. The seed coat, hilum, and micropyle of beans independently correlate with the permeability of beans [9]. The hilum is very porous and is the most important bean structure that absorbs water and is a dominant factor in water inflow [10, 11]. Depending on the type, beans require 12-24 h for the complete absorption of water [12], and beans require 8-10 h to reach a 50% absorption rate [11]. This long soaking time increases preparation costs in order to achieve the desired effect [13]. Hydration limits industrial processing and requires a lot of time, thus necessitating technology that can reduce the time span.
Ultrasonic waves are pressure waves with frequencies exceeding 20 kHz. Ultrasound technology is used in the food industry for multiple purposes such as the pyrolysis of water, formation of radicals, cell destruction by inducing the structural decomposition of solvents and solutes, extraction, activation or inactivation of enzymes, mixing and homogenization, preservation, stabilization, and dissolution and crystallization [14]. As a technology that minimizes processing, ultrasound treatment can be used to preserve food quality while ensuring its safety, and depending on its frequency, it can be applied in food processing, analysis, and quality control [15]. The application of high-power ultrasonic waves in an aqueous medium forms cavitations that generate high shear force and pressure in their collapse [16]. Ghafoor
In the field of food engineering, ultrasound technology is commonly used. Although it has been discovered that ultrasound treatment effectively improves the hydration rate in beans, the optimal conditions of ultrasound treatment for the highest efficacy rate still need to be presented. In addition, the specific conditions demanded by industries can only be satisfied by prediction through modeling. This study has monitored the trend of the improved hydration rate of adzuki beans post-ultrasound treatment and investigated the influence of variables that affect the characteristics of adzuki beans through RSM.
Therefore, the effects of these parameters on the rehydration of adzuki beans were investigated in this study, with the comparison based on changes in the water contents, water activity (
Materials and Methods
Material
The adzuki beans (
Ultrasound Treatment
30 g of adzuki beans and 50 ml of distilled water were placed in a beaker and treated with ultrasound using an ultrasonic processor (VC750, Sonics & Materials, Inc., USA). The beans were treated under various conditions with ultrasound: at power levels of 150-750 W and at time levels of 1-10 min. During treatment, the temperature was maintained at 32 ± 2°C, and the probe of the ultrasonic processor was submerged 2 cm from the surface level. Treated beans were dried at 60°C for an hour and immersed in 150 ml of distilled water. The beans in submergence were preserved at 27°C.
Value of Dependent Variable Determination
Moisture content determination. Upon extracting 3 g of adzuki beans at designated times and drying them superficially with a wiper, the moisture content was determined using a moisture analyzer (MB45, Ohaus Corporation, USA). Using the loss on drying method, the moisture analyzer calculates the loss of mass once an internal halogen dryer heats the sample at 160°C for the complete evaporation of moisture.
Water activity determination. Upon extracting seven adzuki beans at designated times, drying them superficially with a wiper, and crushing them with a hammer, the water activity was determined using a water activity meter (AquaLab 4TE, Meter Group Inc., USA). The water activity meter functions by the dew point measuring method in which the humidity of the sample and air in the chamber equilibrates to a temperature of 25°C and the temperature in which the steam convert to the water activity value.
Hardness determination. Hardness was determined using a texture analyzer (TA-XT plus, Stable Micro Systems Ltd., UK) and modifying the method [18]. The test speed was set as 1 mm/s and the samples were compressed to 90%. Used were a 2 mm cylindrical probe (P/2) and the Return-to-test method analyzing the peak point in which maximum force is applied. For determining the hardness of beans, the P/2 probe is the most commonly used for it measures both the hard seed coat and the cotyledon, which softens as it absorbs water, with its small surface [19]. 10 samples were selected at random, penetrated at the hilum by the probe, averaged, and expressed in (N) units.
Response Surface Methodology (RSM)
The Box-Behnken Design (BBD), an RSM technique involving 3 variables, was deemed appropriate to analyze the relationship and trend of the variables by modeling the curvature of the predicted data [20, 21]. The independent variables and their ranges were set as the soaking time (2-14 h, X1), treatment intensity (150-750 W, X2), and treatment time (1-10 min, X3). The ranges of the three independent variables were encoded as -1, 0, and 1 (minimum value, intermediate value, maximum value), and the ultrasound treatment conditions were set in accordance with the 15-run method. The experiment was conducted with the conditions designed by BBD, and moisture content (Y1), water activity (Y2), and hardness (Y3) were the dependent variables measured that change depending on the independent variables. The dependent variables were expressed by the following quadratic polynomial (Eq. 1).
Statistical Analysis
Values determined were averaged to be used for regression analysis: the moisture content and water activity for each treatment condition were measured 3 times, and the hardness was measured using 10 beans. Results from the experiment were used in regression analysis through the SAS program (RSREG in the Statistical Analysis System; SAS Institute Inc., USA), and the surface plot of the regression equation was presented using the Sigma plot (10 version, Systat Software Inc., Germany). The optimal conditions were predicted using Minitab (Minitab Statistical Software, Minitab Inc., USA). Optimal conditions were determined by setting the dependent variables of moisture content and water activity to the maximum and hardness to the minimum and selecting the best fit amongst the optimal conditions presented through optimization within the experimented range of soaking time, treatment intensity, and treatment time.
Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM)
The changed hilum due to different ultrasound treatments was observed through SEM (JSM-7500F, Jeol Ltd., Japan). First, the samples were dried at 65°C for 24 h in preparation for treatment. Then, they were coated with platinum with a sputter coater (108 Auto, Ted Pella Inc., USA) while attached to carbon tape and enlarged 80 times at an acceleration voltage of 15 kV.
Results and Discussion
Analyzation of Optimal Conditions for Ultrasound Treatment through RSM
RSM is a mathematical and statistical optimization method used to achieve optimal conditions through the modeling and analysis of the trend influenced by multiple variables [22]. BBD is an RSM technique that determines the optimal conditions for optimal results [23].
The independent variables controlling the ultrasound treatment were the soaking time (2-14 h, X1), treatment intensity (150-750 W, X2), and treatment time (1-10 min, X3), set to optimize the hydration rate of the adzuki bean. Under BBD, the ranges of each variable were encoded as 3 levels, designed to have a minimum value, intermediate value, and maximum value of -1, 0, and 1, respectively, as displayed in Table 1. The dependent variables used in the regression analysis to determine the optimal ultrasound treatment conditions were moisture content (Y1), water activity (Y2), and hardness (Y3). Table 2 presents the 15 test conditions including the 3 intermediate values BBD designated and the dependent variables' responses. Table 3 reports the regression equation demonstrating the relationship between the independent and dependent variables, coefficient of determination R2, the
-
Table 1 . Level of independent variables for experimental design.
Factor Independent variable Levels -1 0 1 X1 Soaking time (h) 2 8 14 X2 Processing intensity (W) 150 450 750 X3 Processing time (min) 1 5.5 10
-
Table 2 . Box-behnken design matrices and responses for experimental values.
Run X1 X2 X3 Y1 Y2 Y3 Soaking time (h) Processing intensity (W) Processing time (min) Moisture content (%) Water activity (aw) Hardness (N) 1 2 150 5.5 18.42 0.8576 55.56 2 14 150 5.5 54.98 0.9949 13.73 3 2 750 5.5 35.29 0.9589 19.92 4 14 750 5.5 58.32 0.9936 15.10 5 2 450 1 18.54 0.8193 66.74 6 14 450 1 57.51 0.9952 17.19 7 2 450 10 21.70 0.7832 71.38 8 14 450 10 56.35 0.9933 14.55 9 8 150 1 29.60 0.9123 22.86 10 8 750 1 47.65 0.9825 23.76 11 8 150 10 38.87 0.9857 28.40 12 8 750 10 57.82 0.9960 15.35 13 8 450 5.5 45.45 0.9821 19.28 14 8 450 5.5 41.61 0.9702 21.06 15 8 450 5.5 46.37 0.9861 22.00
-
Table 3 . Polynomial equation calculated by RSM program for ultrasonic treatment conditions of red bean.
Response Quadratic polynomial model R2 F -valuep -valueLack-of-fit Moisture content Y1= -7.306341 +5.548426X1 +0.026775X2 +1.986502X3 -0.106725X12 -0.001879X2X1 +0.000012421X22 -0.040000X3X1 +0.000167X3X2 –0.104177X32 0.9621 14.12 0.0047 0.1678 Water activity Y2= 0.692674 +0.038427X1 +0.000034426X2 +0.021156X3 -0.001383X12 -0.000014250X2X1 +0.000000240X22 +0.000317X3X1 -0.000011093X3X2 -0.001576X32 0.8875 4.38 0.0591 0.0260 Hardness Y3= 83.837276 –10.723843X1 +0.026619X2 –3.265617X3 +0.349583X12 +0.005140X2X1 –0.000080972X22 –0.067407X3X1 –0.002583X3X2 +0.449383X32 0.9019 5.11 0.0437 0.0111
-
Table 4 . Estimated coefficients of quadratic polynomial equation for different response.
Y1 Y2 Y3 Coefficient P-value Coefficient P-value Coefficient P-value Intercept -7.306341 0.5156 0.692674 0.0005 83.837276 0.0137 X1 5.548426 0.0094 0.038427 0.0200 -10.723843 0.0144 X2 0.026775 0.3956 0.000034426 0.8929 0.026619 0.6862 X3 1.986502 0.3037 0.021156 0.2073 -3.265617 0.4221 X1*X1 -0.106725 0.1773 -0.001383 0.0606 0.349583 0.0628 X2*X1 -0.001879 0.2099 -0.000014250 0.2522 0.005140 0.1275 X2*X2 0.000012421 0.6670 0.000000240 0.3435 -0.000080972 0.2257 X3*X1 -0.040000 0.6653 0.000317 0.6842 -0.067407 0.7342 X3*X2 0.000167 0.9275 -0.000011093 0.4840 -0.002583 0.5221 X3*X3 -0.104177 0.4282 -0.001576 0.1825 0.449383 0.1452
Moisture Content
Moisture content affects characteristics such as conductivity to heat and electricity and density and affects the design of technical processes [24]. Since moisture exists in high quantities in food and its surrounding atmosphere, moisture content is a commonly completed analysis in the food industry. According to the analysis of variance (ANOVA), the R2 value of the regression equation was 0.9621, proving the model appropriate, and the
-
Fig. 1. Response surface plot for moisture content of Adzuki bean.
(A) the effect of soaking time and processing intensity, (B) the effect of soaking time and processing time, (C) the effect of processing intensity and processing time.
Water Activity
Typically water activity differs depending on the characteristics of the product such as its structure, effect of solvents, and surface activity [26]. Change in water activity is one of the leading causes of change in food quality and is a commonly completed analysis with moisture content. According to the results of ANOVA, the R2 value of the total model of the regression equation was 0.8875 and the
-
Fig. 2. Response surface plot for water activity of Adzuki bean.
(A) the effect of soaking time and processing intensity, (B) the effect of soaking time and processing time, (C) the effect of processing intensity and processing time.
Hardness
The hydration of the adzuki bean is an effective method to reduce its hard texture. The hardness of a bean is an important evaluator of its physical characteristics. According to ANOVA, the R2 value of the total model of the regression equation was 0.9019, showing high explanatory power, and the
-
Fig. 3. Response surface plot for hardness of Adzuki bean.
(A) the effect of soaking time and processing intensity, (B) the effect of soaking time and processing time, (C) the effect of processing intensity and processing time.
Optimum Condition
Based on each dependent variablés regression equation and graph, the optimal treatment conditions and their predicted values of dependent variables are represented in Table 5. The optimal ultrasound treatment conditions were an immersion time of 12.9 h, treatment intensity of 600 W, and treatment time of 8.65 min when maximizing the moisture content and water activity while minimizing the hardness. The values predicted for the dependent variables were a moisture content of 58.32%, water activity of 0.9979 aw, and hardness of 14.63 N. When experimenting with the optimal conditions determined by RSM, the results obtained were a moisture content of 58.28 ± 0.56%, water activity of 0.9885 ± 0.0040 aw, and hardness of 13.01 ± 2.82 N, the experimented values confirming a 95% confidence interval except for the water activity. Values of water activity are accepted as accurate within an error range of 0.01 aw in the food industry to determine if the value has reached a critical zone in which decomposition reaction can occur [26].
-
Table 5 . Comparison between predicted and observed values of response variables within the range of the optimum condition.
Response Predicted condition Predicted value Experimental value Moisture content 12.9 h, 600 W, 8.65 min 58.32% 58.28±0.56% Water activity 0.9979 aw 0.9885±0.0040 aw Hardness 14.63 N 13.01±2.82 N
Scanning Electron Microscopy of the Bean Hilum
The seed coat of the adzuki bean is highly impermeable, hence the hilum has a large effect on the hydration of the beans [29]. The changes in the hilum were observed through SEM, and Fig. 4A displays the conditions of the hilum that have undergone various ultrasound treatments. Depending on the treatment, abrasions and crevices of the hilum were exacerbated, and the prolonged treatment time produced a rough hilum due to the larger scale abrasions (450 W, 5.5 min) and crevices formed in the later stage of treatment in the central part of the hilum (450 W, 10 min). Changes to the hilum due to the treatment time were equally damaging in treatment intensities of 150 W and 750 W, but the treatment at 150 W did not produce crevices in the hilum whereas the treatment at 750 W did within a minute of treatment. The adzuki bean treated at 750 W for 10 min showed damage in areas other than the hilum as it produced a large hole in its surface (Fig. 4B). Through these observations, it was demonstrated that the surface layer of the hilum formed abrasions and crevices due to the strong shear force of the ultrasound treatment, and the increase in treatment intensity and time gradually intensified the damage on the surface.
-
Fig. 4. Scanning electron micrographs of Adzuki beans sonicated various conditions (X80).
(A) Scanning electron micrographs of Adzuki beans hilum sonicated at different levels of amplitude and time, (B) Surface of red beans sonicated at 750 W for 10 min.
Conclusion
This study analyzed the optimal conditions for an increase in the hydration rate of adzuki beans. The sonication process helped in the diffusion of moisture in Adzuki beans. All dependent variables were highly affected by the independent variables in the order of soaking time, treatment time, and treatment intensity. The optimal conditions for treatment analyzed through RSM were an immersion time of 12.9 h, treatment intensity of 600 W, and treatment time of 8.65 min, and the experimented values proved similar to the predicted values. Appropriate ultrasound treatment increased the rate of hydration by producing abrasions and crevices in the hilum through which the bean absorbs water, but extreme treatment damaged the surface of the bean as well by creating large crevices. The optimal conditions for ultrasound treatment were determined in this study for the treatment of red beans, and the predictive model presented by the study is expected to provide specific treatment conditions required by industries in addition to the optimal ones.
Acknowledgment
This work was supported by Gachon University research fund of 2020 (GCU-202008490008), and a grant (22193MFDS468 from ministry of food and drug safety in 2022.
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no financial conflicts of interest to declare.
References
- Li H, Zou L, Li XY, Wu DT, Liu HY, Li HB,
et al . 2022. Adzuki bean (Vigna angularis ): chemical compositions, physicochemical properties, health benefits, and food applications.Compr. Rev. Food Sci. Food Saf. 21 : 2335-2362. - Song SB, Seo HI, Ko JY, Lee JS, Kang JR, Oh BG,
et al . 2011. Quality characteristics of adzuki beans sediment according to variety.J. Korean Soc. Food Sci. Nutr. 40 : 1121-1127. - Yousif AM, Deeth HC, Caffin NA, Lisle AT. 2002. Effect of storage time and conditions on the hardness and cooking quality of adzuki (
Vigna angularis ).Lebensm-Wiss Technol. 35 : 338-343. - Han KH, Fukushima M, Ohba K, Shimada K, Sekikawa M, Chiji H,
et al . 2004. Hepatoprotective effects of the water extract from adzuki bean hulls on acetaminophen-induced damage in rat liver.J. Nutr. Sci. Vitaminol. 50 : 380-383. - Liu YP, Wang QY, Li SS, Yue YF, Ma YL, Ren GX. 2018. Convenient food made of extruded adzuki bean attenuates inflammation and improves glycemic control in patients with type 2 diabetes: a randomized controlled trial.
Ther. Clin. Risk Manag. 14 : 871-884. - Kitano-Okada T, Nagata R, Han KH, Mikami N, Satoh K, Nishihira J,
et al . 2019. Safety and efficacy of adzuki bean extract in subjects with moderate to high LDL-C: a randomized trial.Biosci Biotech Bioch. 83 : 933-941. - Itoh T, Furuichi Y. 2009. Lowering serum cholesterol level by feeding a 40% ethanol-eluted fraction from HP-20 resin treated with hot water extract of adzuki beans (
Vigna angularis ) to rats fed a high-fat cholesterol diet.Nutrition 25 : 318-321. - Oh SM, Jo YJ, Chun A, Kwak J, Oh YG, Kim MJ,
et al . 2021. Seed and water absorption characteristics of red bean cultivars in Korea.Korean J. Food Sci. Technol. 53 : 607-612. - Reyesmoreno C, Paredeslopez O. 1993. Hard-to-cook phenomenon in common beans - a review.
Crit. Rev. Food Sci. 33 : 227-286. - Miano AC, Augusto PED. 2015. From the sigmoidal to the downward concave shape behavior during the hydration of grains: Effect of the initial moisture content on Adzuki beans (
Vigna angularis ).Food Bioprod. Process 96 : 43-51. - Yousif AM, Kato J, Deeth HC. 2007. Effect of storage on the biochemical structure and processing quality of adzuki bean (
Vigna angularis ).Food Rev. Int. 23 : 1-33. - Piergiovanni AR. 2011. Kinetic of water adsorption in common bean: Considerations on the suitability of Peleg's model for describing bean hydration.
J. Food Process Pres. 35 : 447-452. - Kinyanju PK, Njoroge DM, Makokha AO, Christiaens S, Ndaka DS, Hendrickx M. 2015. Hydration properties and texture fingerprints of easy- and hard-to-cook bean varieties.
Food Sci. Nutr. 3 : 39-47. - Gallo M, Ferrara L, Naviglio D. 2018. Application of ultrasound in food science and technology: a perspective.
Foods 7 : 164. - Arvanitoyannis IS, Kotsanopoulos KV, Savva AG. 2017. Use of ultrasounds in the food industry-Methods and effects on quality, safety, and organoleptic characteristics of foods: a review.
Crit. Rev. Food Sci. 57 : 109-128. - Suslick KS, Hammerton DA, Cline RE. 1986. Sonochemical hot spot.
J. Am. Chem. Soc. 108 : 5641-5642. - Ghafoor M, Misra NN, Mahadevan K, Tiwari BK. 2014. Ultrasound assisted hydration of navy beans (
Phaseolus vulgaris ).Ultrason. Sonochem. 21 : 409-414. - Siqueira BD, Vianello RP, Frenandes KF, Bassinello PZ. 2013. Hardness of carioca beans (
Phaseolus vulgaris L.) as affected by cooking methods.Lwt-Food Sci. Technol. 54 : 13-17. - Revilla I, Vivar-Quintana AM. 2008. Effect of canning process on texture of Faba beans (
Vicia Faba ).Food Chem. 106 : 310-314. - Tirado-Kulieva VA, Sanchez-Chero M, Villegasyarleque M, Aguilar GFV, Carrion-Barc G, Santa Cruz AGY,
et al . 2021. An overview on the use of response surface methodology to model and optimize extraction processes in the food industry.Curr. Res. Nutr. Food Sci. 9 : 745-754. - Sharafinia S, Farrokhnia A, Lemraski EG. 2022. Optimized safranin adsorption onto poly(vinylidene fluoride)-based nanofiber via response surface methodology.
Mater. Chem. Phys. 276 : 125407. - Yancheshmeh BS, Panahi Y, Allahdad Z, Abdolshahi A, Zamani Z. 2022. Optimization of ultrasound-assisted extraction of bioactive compounds from
Achillea kellalensis using response surface methodology.J. Appl. Res. Med. Aroma. Plants 28 : 100355. - Said KAM, Amin MAM. 2015. Overview on the response surface methodology (RSM) in extraction processes.
J. Appl. Sci. Process Eng. 2 : 8-17. - Isengard HD. 2001. Water content, one of the most important properties of food.
Food Control 12 : 395-400. - Ulloa JA, Enriquez Lopez KV, Contreras Morales YB, Rosas Ulloa P, Ramírez Ramírez JC, Ulloa Rangel BE. 2015. Effect of ultrasound treatment on the hydration kinetics and cooking times of dry beans (
Phaseolus vulgaris ).Cyta-J. Food 13 : 588-596. - Mathlouthi M. 2001. Water content, water activity, water structure and the stability of foodstuffs.
Food Control 12 : 409-417. - Mothibe KJ, Zhang M, Mujumdar AS, Wang YC, Cheng XF. 2014. Effects of ultrasound and microwave pretreatments of apple before spouted bed drying on rate of dehydration and physical properties.
Dry Technol. 32 : 1848-1856. - Li P, Li Y, Wang L, Zhang H, Qi XG, Qian HF. 2020. Study on water absorption kinetics of black beans during soaking.
J. Food Eng. 283 : 110030. - Miano AC, Sabadoti VD, Augusto PED. 2018. Enhancing the hydration process of common beans by ultrasound and high temperatures: Impact on cooking and thermodynamic properties.
J. Food Eng. 225 : 53-61.
Related articles in JMB
Article
Research article
J. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 2024; 34(4): 846-853
Published online April 28, 2024 https://doi.org/10.4014/jmb.2401.01004
Copyright © The Korean Society for Microbiology and Biotechnology.
Optimization of Ultrasound-Assisted Pretreatment for Accelerating Rehydration of Adzuki Bean (Vigna angularis)
Hyengseop Kim1†, Changgeun Lee1†, Eunghee Kim2, Youngje Jo3, Jiyoon Park4, Choongjin Ban5*, and Seokwon Lim1*
1Department of Food Science and Biotechnology, Gachon University, Seongnam 13120, Republic of Korea
2Smart Food Manufacturing Project Group, Korea Food Research Institute, Wanju 55365, Republic of Korea.
3Research and Development Dept., B.E.T., Busan 48119, Republic of Korea
4Seoul International School, Seongnam 13113, Republic of Korea
5Department of Environmental Horticulture, University of Seoul, Seoul 02504, Republic of Korea
Correspondence to:Choongjin Ban, pahncj@uos.ac.kr
Seokwon Lim, slim@gachon.ac.kr
†These authors contributed equally to this work.
Abstract
Adzuki bean (Vigna angularis), which provides plant-based proteins and functional substances, requires a long soaking time during processing, which limits its usefulness to industries and consumers. To improve this, ultrasonic treatment using high pressure and shear force was judged to be an appropriate pretreatment method. This study aimed to determine the optimal conditions of ultrasound treatment for the improved hydration of adzuki beans using the response surface methodology (RSM). Independent variables chosen to regulate the hydration process of the adzuki beans were the soaking time (2-14 h, X1), treatment intensity (150-750 W, X2), and treatment time (1-10 min, X3). Dependent variables chosen to assess the differences in the beans post-immersion were moisture content, water activity, and hardness. The optimal conditions for treatment deduced through RSM were a soaking time of 12.9 h, treatment intensity of 600 W, and treatment time of 8.65 min. In this optimal condition, the values predicted for the dependent variables were a moisture content of 58.32%, water activity of 0.9979 aw, and hardness of 14.63 N. Upon experimentation, the results obtained were a moisture content of 58.28 ± 0.56%, water activity of 0.9885 ± 0.0040 aw, and hardness of 13.01 ± 2.82 g, confirming results similar to the predicted values. Proper ultrasound treatment caused cracks in the hilum, which greatly affects the water absorption of adzuki beans, accelerating the rate of hydration. These results are expected to help determine economically efficient processing conditions for specific purposes, in addition to solving industrial problems associated with the low hydration rate of adzuki beans.
Keywords: Adzuki bean, sonication pre-treatment, increased water absorption, optimal processing condition, response surface methodology
Introduction
The adzuki bean (
Beans, including adzuki beans are important suppliers of plant-based proteins and functional substances but require hydration for processes such as germination and fermentation [8]. In the seed coat of beans are the hilum, a scar marking the former attachment of the bean to the plant stalk, and the micropyle, a microscopic hole. The seed coat, hilum, and micropyle of beans independently correlate with the permeability of beans [9]. The hilum is very porous and is the most important bean structure that absorbs water and is a dominant factor in water inflow [10, 11]. Depending on the type, beans require 12-24 h for the complete absorption of water [12], and beans require 8-10 h to reach a 50% absorption rate [11]. This long soaking time increases preparation costs in order to achieve the desired effect [13]. Hydration limits industrial processing and requires a lot of time, thus necessitating technology that can reduce the time span.
Ultrasonic waves are pressure waves with frequencies exceeding 20 kHz. Ultrasound technology is used in the food industry for multiple purposes such as the pyrolysis of water, formation of radicals, cell destruction by inducing the structural decomposition of solvents and solutes, extraction, activation or inactivation of enzymes, mixing and homogenization, preservation, stabilization, and dissolution and crystallization [14]. As a technology that minimizes processing, ultrasound treatment can be used to preserve food quality while ensuring its safety, and depending on its frequency, it can be applied in food processing, analysis, and quality control [15]. The application of high-power ultrasonic waves in an aqueous medium forms cavitations that generate high shear force and pressure in their collapse [16]. Ghafoor
In the field of food engineering, ultrasound technology is commonly used. Although it has been discovered that ultrasound treatment effectively improves the hydration rate in beans, the optimal conditions of ultrasound treatment for the highest efficacy rate still need to be presented. In addition, the specific conditions demanded by industries can only be satisfied by prediction through modeling. This study has monitored the trend of the improved hydration rate of adzuki beans post-ultrasound treatment and investigated the influence of variables that affect the characteristics of adzuki beans through RSM.
Therefore, the effects of these parameters on the rehydration of adzuki beans were investigated in this study, with the comparison based on changes in the water contents, water activity (
Materials and Methods
Material
The adzuki beans (
Ultrasound Treatment
30 g of adzuki beans and 50 ml of distilled water were placed in a beaker and treated with ultrasound using an ultrasonic processor (VC750, Sonics & Materials, Inc., USA). The beans were treated under various conditions with ultrasound: at power levels of 150-750 W and at time levels of 1-10 min. During treatment, the temperature was maintained at 32 ± 2°C, and the probe of the ultrasonic processor was submerged 2 cm from the surface level. Treated beans were dried at 60°C for an hour and immersed in 150 ml of distilled water. The beans in submergence were preserved at 27°C.
Value of Dependent Variable Determination
Moisture content determination. Upon extracting 3 g of adzuki beans at designated times and drying them superficially with a wiper, the moisture content was determined using a moisture analyzer (MB45, Ohaus Corporation, USA). Using the loss on drying method, the moisture analyzer calculates the loss of mass once an internal halogen dryer heats the sample at 160°C for the complete evaporation of moisture.
Water activity determination. Upon extracting seven adzuki beans at designated times, drying them superficially with a wiper, and crushing them with a hammer, the water activity was determined using a water activity meter (AquaLab 4TE, Meter Group Inc., USA). The water activity meter functions by the dew point measuring method in which the humidity of the sample and air in the chamber equilibrates to a temperature of 25°C and the temperature in which the steam convert to the water activity value.
Hardness determination. Hardness was determined using a texture analyzer (TA-XT plus, Stable Micro Systems Ltd., UK) and modifying the method [18]. The test speed was set as 1 mm/s and the samples were compressed to 90%. Used were a 2 mm cylindrical probe (P/2) and the Return-to-test method analyzing the peak point in which maximum force is applied. For determining the hardness of beans, the P/2 probe is the most commonly used for it measures both the hard seed coat and the cotyledon, which softens as it absorbs water, with its small surface [19]. 10 samples were selected at random, penetrated at the hilum by the probe, averaged, and expressed in (N) units.
Response Surface Methodology (RSM)
The Box-Behnken Design (BBD), an RSM technique involving 3 variables, was deemed appropriate to analyze the relationship and trend of the variables by modeling the curvature of the predicted data [20, 21]. The independent variables and their ranges were set as the soaking time (2-14 h, X1), treatment intensity (150-750 W, X2), and treatment time (1-10 min, X3). The ranges of the three independent variables were encoded as -1, 0, and 1 (minimum value, intermediate value, maximum value), and the ultrasound treatment conditions were set in accordance with the 15-run method. The experiment was conducted with the conditions designed by BBD, and moisture content (Y1), water activity (Y2), and hardness (Y3) were the dependent variables measured that change depending on the independent variables. The dependent variables were expressed by the following quadratic polynomial (Eq. 1).
Statistical Analysis
Values determined were averaged to be used for regression analysis: the moisture content and water activity for each treatment condition were measured 3 times, and the hardness was measured using 10 beans. Results from the experiment were used in regression analysis through the SAS program (RSREG in the Statistical Analysis System; SAS Institute Inc., USA), and the surface plot of the regression equation was presented using the Sigma plot (10 version, Systat Software Inc., Germany). The optimal conditions were predicted using Minitab (Minitab Statistical Software, Minitab Inc., USA). Optimal conditions were determined by setting the dependent variables of moisture content and water activity to the maximum and hardness to the minimum and selecting the best fit amongst the optimal conditions presented through optimization within the experimented range of soaking time, treatment intensity, and treatment time.
Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM)
The changed hilum due to different ultrasound treatments was observed through SEM (JSM-7500F, Jeol Ltd., Japan). First, the samples were dried at 65°C for 24 h in preparation for treatment. Then, they were coated with platinum with a sputter coater (108 Auto, Ted Pella Inc., USA) while attached to carbon tape and enlarged 80 times at an acceleration voltage of 15 kV.
Results and Discussion
Analyzation of Optimal Conditions for Ultrasound Treatment through RSM
RSM is a mathematical and statistical optimization method used to achieve optimal conditions through the modeling and analysis of the trend influenced by multiple variables [22]. BBD is an RSM technique that determines the optimal conditions for optimal results [23].
The independent variables controlling the ultrasound treatment were the soaking time (2-14 h, X1), treatment intensity (150-750 W, X2), and treatment time (1-10 min, X3), set to optimize the hydration rate of the adzuki bean. Under BBD, the ranges of each variable were encoded as 3 levels, designed to have a minimum value, intermediate value, and maximum value of -1, 0, and 1, respectively, as displayed in Table 1. The dependent variables used in the regression analysis to determine the optimal ultrasound treatment conditions were moisture content (Y1), water activity (Y2), and hardness (Y3). Table 2 presents the 15 test conditions including the 3 intermediate values BBD designated and the dependent variables' responses. Table 3 reports the regression equation demonstrating the relationship between the independent and dependent variables, coefficient of determination R2, the
-
Table 1 . Level of independent variables for experimental design..
Factor Independent variable Levels -1 0 1 X1 Soaking time (h) 2 8 14 X2 Processing intensity (W) 150 450 750 X3 Processing time (min) 1 5.5 10
-
Table 2 . Box-behnken design matrices and responses for experimental values..
Run X1 X2 X3 Y1 Y2 Y3 Soaking time (h) Processing intensity (W) Processing time (min) Moisture content (%) Water activity (aw) Hardness (N) 1 2 150 5.5 18.42 0.8576 55.56 2 14 150 5.5 54.98 0.9949 13.73 3 2 750 5.5 35.29 0.9589 19.92 4 14 750 5.5 58.32 0.9936 15.10 5 2 450 1 18.54 0.8193 66.74 6 14 450 1 57.51 0.9952 17.19 7 2 450 10 21.70 0.7832 71.38 8 14 450 10 56.35 0.9933 14.55 9 8 150 1 29.60 0.9123 22.86 10 8 750 1 47.65 0.9825 23.76 11 8 150 10 38.87 0.9857 28.40 12 8 750 10 57.82 0.9960 15.35 13 8 450 5.5 45.45 0.9821 19.28 14 8 450 5.5 41.61 0.9702 21.06 15 8 450 5.5 46.37 0.9861 22.00
-
Table 3 . Polynomial equation calculated by RSM program for ultrasonic treatment conditions of red bean..
Response Quadratic polynomial model R2 F -valuep -valueLack-of-fit Moisture content Y1= -7.306341 +5.548426X1 +0.026775X2 +1.986502X3 -0.106725X12 -0.001879X2X1 +0.000012421X22 -0.040000X3X1 +0.000167X3X2 –0.104177X32 0.9621 14.12 0.0047 0.1678 Water activity Y2= 0.692674 +0.038427X1 +0.000034426X2 +0.021156X3 -0.001383X12 -0.000014250X2X1 +0.000000240X22 +0.000317X3X1 -0.000011093X3X2 -0.001576X32 0.8875 4.38 0.0591 0.0260 Hardness Y3= 83.837276 –10.723843X1 +0.026619X2 –3.265617X3 +0.349583X12 +0.005140X2X1 –0.000080972X22 –0.067407X3X1 –0.002583X3X2 +0.449383X32 0.9019 5.11 0.0437 0.0111
-
Table 4 . Estimated coefficients of quadratic polynomial equation for different response..
Y1 Y2 Y3 Coefficient P-value Coefficient P-value Coefficient P-value Intercept -7.306341 0.5156 0.692674 0.0005 83.837276 0.0137 X1 5.548426 0.0094 0.038427 0.0200 -10.723843 0.0144 X2 0.026775 0.3956 0.000034426 0.8929 0.026619 0.6862 X3 1.986502 0.3037 0.021156 0.2073 -3.265617 0.4221 X1*X1 -0.106725 0.1773 -0.001383 0.0606 0.349583 0.0628 X2*X1 -0.001879 0.2099 -0.000014250 0.2522 0.005140 0.1275 X2*X2 0.000012421 0.6670 0.000000240 0.3435 -0.000080972 0.2257 X3*X1 -0.040000 0.6653 0.000317 0.6842 -0.067407 0.7342 X3*X2 0.000167 0.9275 -0.000011093 0.4840 -0.002583 0.5221 X3*X3 -0.104177 0.4282 -0.001576 0.1825 0.449383 0.1452
Moisture Content
Moisture content affects characteristics such as conductivity to heat and electricity and density and affects the design of technical processes [24]. Since moisture exists in high quantities in food and its surrounding atmosphere, moisture content is a commonly completed analysis in the food industry. According to the analysis of variance (ANOVA), the R2 value of the regression equation was 0.9621, proving the model appropriate, and the
-
Figure 1. Response surface plot for moisture content of Adzuki bean.
(A) the effect of soaking time and processing intensity, (B) the effect of soaking time and processing time, (C) the effect of processing intensity and processing time.
Water Activity
Typically water activity differs depending on the characteristics of the product such as its structure, effect of solvents, and surface activity [26]. Change in water activity is one of the leading causes of change in food quality and is a commonly completed analysis with moisture content. According to the results of ANOVA, the R2 value of the total model of the regression equation was 0.8875 and the
-
Figure 2. Response surface plot for water activity of Adzuki bean.
(A) the effect of soaking time and processing intensity, (B) the effect of soaking time and processing time, (C) the effect of processing intensity and processing time.
Hardness
The hydration of the adzuki bean is an effective method to reduce its hard texture. The hardness of a bean is an important evaluator of its physical characteristics. According to ANOVA, the R2 value of the total model of the regression equation was 0.9019, showing high explanatory power, and the
-
Figure 3. Response surface plot for hardness of Adzuki bean.
(A) the effect of soaking time and processing intensity, (B) the effect of soaking time and processing time, (C) the effect of processing intensity and processing time.
Optimum Condition
Based on each dependent variablés regression equation and graph, the optimal treatment conditions and their predicted values of dependent variables are represented in Table 5. The optimal ultrasound treatment conditions were an immersion time of 12.9 h, treatment intensity of 600 W, and treatment time of 8.65 min when maximizing the moisture content and water activity while minimizing the hardness. The values predicted for the dependent variables were a moisture content of 58.32%, water activity of 0.9979 aw, and hardness of 14.63 N. When experimenting with the optimal conditions determined by RSM, the results obtained were a moisture content of 58.28 ± 0.56%, water activity of 0.9885 ± 0.0040 aw, and hardness of 13.01 ± 2.82 N, the experimented values confirming a 95% confidence interval except for the water activity. Values of water activity are accepted as accurate within an error range of 0.01 aw in the food industry to determine if the value has reached a critical zone in which decomposition reaction can occur [26].
-
Table 5 . Comparison between predicted and observed values of response variables within the range of the optimum condition..
Response Predicted condition Predicted value Experimental value Moisture content 12.9 h, 600 W, 8.65 min 58.32% 58.28±0.56% Water activity 0.9979 aw 0.9885±0.0040 aw Hardness 14.63 N 13.01±2.82 N
Scanning Electron Microscopy of the Bean Hilum
The seed coat of the adzuki bean is highly impermeable, hence the hilum has a large effect on the hydration of the beans [29]. The changes in the hilum were observed through SEM, and Fig. 4A displays the conditions of the hilum that have undergone various ultrasound treatments. Depending on the treatment, abrasions and crevices of the hilum were exacerbated, and the prolonged treatment time produced a rough hilum due to the larger scale abrasions (450 W, 5.5 min) and crevices formed in the later stage of treatment in the central part of the hilum (450 W, 10 min). Changes to the hilum due to the treatment time were equally damaging in treatment intensities of 150 W and 750 W, but the treatment at 150 W did not produce crevices in the hilum whereas the treatment at 750 W did within a minute of treatment. The adzuki bean treated at 750 W for 10 min showed damage in areas other than the hilum as it produced a large hole in its surface (Fig. 4B). Through these observations, it was demonstrated that the surface layer of the hilum formed abrasions and crevices due to the strong shear force of the ultrasound treatment, and the increase in treatment intensity and time gradually intensified the damage on the surface.
-
Figure 4. Scanning electron micrographs of Adzuki beans sonicated various conditions (X80).
(A) Scanning electron micrographs of Adzuki beans hilum sonicated at different levels of amplitude and time, (B) Surface of red beans sonicated at 750 W for 10 min.
Conclusion
This study analyzed the optimal conditions for an increase in the hydration rate of adzuki beans. The sonication process helped in the diffusion of moisture in Adzuki beans. All dependent variables were highly affected by the independent variables in the order of soaking time, treatment time, and treatment intensity. The optimal conditions for treatment analyzed through RSM were an immersion time of 12.9 h, treatment intensity of 600 W, and treatment time of 8.65 min, and the experimented values proved similar to the predicted values. Appropriate ultrasound treatment increased the rate of hydration by producing abrasions and crevices in the hilum through which the bean absorbs water, but extreme treatment damaged the surface of the bean as well by creating large crevices. The optimal conditions for ultrasound treatment were determined in this study for the treatment of red beans, and the predictive model presented by the study is expected to provide specific treatment conditions required by industries in addition to the optimal ones.
Acknowledgment
This work was supported by Gachon University research fund of 2020 (GCU-202008490008), and a grant (22193MFDS468 from ministry of food and drug safety in 2022.
Conflict of Interest
The authors have no financial conflicts of interest to declare.
Fig 1.
Fig 2.
Fig 3.
Fig 4.
-
Table 1 . Level of independent variables for experimental design..
Factor Independent variable Levels -1 0 1 X1 Soaking time (h) 2 8 14 X2 Processing intensity (W) 150 450 750 X3 Processing time (min) 1 5.5 10
-
Table 2 . Box-behnken design matrices and responses for experimental values..
Run X1 X2 X3 Y1 Y2 Y3 Soaking time (h) Processing intensity (W) Processing time (min) Moisture content (%) Water activity (aw) Hardness (N) 1 2 150 5.5 18.42 0.8576 55.56 2 14 150 5.5 54.98 0.9949 13.73 3 2 750 5.5 35.29 0.9589 19.92 4 14 750 5.5 58.32 0.9936 15.10 5 2 450 1 18.54 0.8193 66.74 6 14 450 1 57.51 0.9952 17.19 7 2 450 10 21.70 0.7832 71.38 8 14 450 10 56.35 0.9933 14.55 9 8 150 1 29.60 0.9123 22.86 10 8 750 1 47.65 0.9825 23.76 11 8 150 10 38.87 0.9857 28.40 12 8 750 10 57.82 0.9960 15.35 13 8 450 5.5 45.45 0.9821 19.28 14 8 450 5.5 41.61 0.9702 21.06 15 8 450 5.5 46.37 0.9861 22.00
-
Table 3 . Polynomial equation calculated by RSM program for ultrasonic treatment conditions of red bean..
Response Quadratic polynomial model R2 F -valuep -valueLack-of-fit Moisture content Y1= -7.306341 +5.548426X1 +0.026775X2 +1.986502X3 -0.106725X12 -0.001879X2X1 +0.000012421X22 -0.040000X3X1 +0.000167X3X2 –0.104177X32 0.9621 14.12 0.0047 0.1678 Water activity Y2= 0.692674 +0.038427X1 +0.000034426X2 +0.021156X3 -0.001383X12 -0.000014250X2X1 +0.000000240X22 +0.000317X3X1 -0.000011093X3X2 -0.001576X32 0.8875 4.38 0.0591 0.0260 Hardness Y3= 83.837276 –10.723843X1 +0.026619X2 –3.265617X3 +0.349583X12 +0.005140X2X1 –0.000080972X22 –0.067407X3X1 –0.002583X3X2 +0.449383X32 0.9019 5.11 0.0437 0.0111
-
Table 4 . Estimated coefficients of quadratic polynomial equation for different response..
Y1 Y2 Y3 Coefficient P-value Coefficient P-value Coefficient P-value Intercept -7.306341 0.5156 0.692674 0.0005 83.837276 0.0137 X1 5.548426 0.0094 0.038427 0.0200 -10.723843 0.0144 X2 0.026775 0.3956 0.000034426 0.8929 0.026619 0.6862 X3 1.986502 0.3037 0.021156 0.2073 -3.265617 0.4221 X1*X1 -0.106725 0.1773 -0.001383 0.0606 0.349583 0.0628 X2*X1 -0.001879 0.2099 -0.000014250 0.2522 0.005140 0.1275 X2*X2 0.000012421 0.6670 0.000000240 0.3435 -0.000080972 0.2257 X3*X1 -0.040000 0.6653 0.000317 0.6842 -0.067407 0.7342 X3*X2 0.000167 0.9275 -0.000011093 0.4840 -0.002583 0.5221 X3*X3 -0.104177 0.4282 -0.001576 0.1825 0.449383 0.1452
-
Table 5 . Comparison between predicted and observed values of response variables within the range of the optimum condition..
Response Predicted condition Predicted value Experimental value Moisture content 12.9 h, 600 W, 8.65 min 58.32% 58.28±0.56% Water activity 0.9979 aw 0.9885±0.0040 aw Hardness 14.63 N 13.01±2.82 N
References
- Li H, Zou L, Li XY, Wu DT, Liu HY, Li HB,
et al . 2022. Adzuki bean (Vigna angularis ): chemical compositions, physicochemical properties, health benefits, and food applications.Compr. Rev. Food Sci. Food Saf. 21 : 2335-2362. - Song SB, Seo HI, Ko JY, Lee JS, Kang JR, Oh BG,
et al . 2011. Quality characteristics of adzuki beans sediment according to variety.J. Korean Soc. Food Sci. Nutr. 40 : 1121-1127. - Yousif AM, Deeth HC, Caffin NA, Lisle AT. 2002. Effect of storage time and conditions on the hardness and cooking quality of adzuki (
Vigna angularis ).Lebensm-Wiss Technol. 35 : 338-343. - Han KH, Fukushima M, Ohba K, Shimada K, Sekikawa M, Chiji H,
et al . 2004. Hepatoprotective effects of the water extract from adzuki bean hulls on acetaminophen-induced damage in rat liver.J. Nutr. Sci. Vitaminol. 50 : 380-383. - Liu YP, Wang QY, Li SS, Yue YF, Ma YL, Ren GX. 2018. Convenient food made of extruded adzuki bean attenuates inflammation and improves glycemic control in patients with type 2 diabetes: a randomized controlled trial.
Ther. Clin. Risk Manag. 14 : 871-884. - Kitano-Okada T, Nagata R, Han KH, Mikami N, Satoh K, Nishihira J,
et al . 2019. Safety and efficacy of adzuki bean extract in subjects with moderate to high LDL-C: a randomized trial.Biosci Biotech Bioch. 83 : 933-941. - Itoh T, Furuichi Y. 2009. Lowering serum cholesterol level by feeding a 40% ethanol-eluted fraction from HP-20 resin treated with hot water extract of adzuki beans (
Vigna angularis ) to rats fed a high-fat cholesterol diet.Nutrition 25 : 318-321. - Oh SM, Jo YJ, Chun A, Kwak J, Oh YG, Kim MJ,
et al . 2021. Seed and water absorption characteristics of red bean cultivars in Korea.Korean J. Food Sci. Technol. 53 : 607-612. - Reyesmoreno C, Paredeslopez O. 1993. Hard-to-cook phenomenon in common beans - a review.
Crit. Rev. Food Sci. 33 : 227-286. - Miano AC, Augusto PED. 2015. From the sigmoidal to the downward concave shape behavior during the hydration of grains: Effect of the initial moisture content on Adzuki beans (
Vigna angularis ).Food Bioprod. Process 96 : 43-51. - Yousif AM, Kato J, Deeth HC. 2007. Effect of storage on the biochemical structure and processing quality of adzuki bean (
Vigna angularis ).Food Rev. Int. 23 : 1-33. - Piergiovanni AR. 2011. Kinetic of water adsorption in common bean: Considerations on the suitability of Peleg's model for describing bean hydration.
J. Food Process Pres. 35 : 447-452. - Kinyanju PK, Njoroge DM, Makokha AO, Christiaens S, Ndaka DS, Hendrickx M. 2015. Hydration properties and texture fingerprints of easy- and hard-to-cook bean varieties.
Food Sci. Nutr. 3 : 39-47. - Gallo M, Ferrara L, Naviglio D. 2018. Application of ultrasound in food science and technology: a perspective.
Foods 7 : 164. - Arvanitoyannis IS, Kotsanopoulos KV, Savva AG. 2017. Use of ultrasounds in the food industry-Methods and effects on quality, safety, and organoleptic characteristics of foods: a review.
Crit. Rev. Food Sci. 57 : 109-128. - Suslick KS, Hammerton DA, Cline RE. 1986. Sonochemical hot spot.
J. Am. Chem. Soc. 108 : 5641-5642. - Ghafoor M, Misra NN, Mahadevan K, Tiwari BK. 2014. Ultrasound assisted hydration of navy beans (
Phaseolus vulgaris ).Ultrason. Sonochem. 21 : 409-414. - Siqueira BD, Vianello RP, Frenandes KF, Bassinello PZ. 2013. Hardness of carioca beans (
Phaseolus vulgaris L.) as affected by cooking methods.Lwt-Food Sci. Technol. 54 : 13-17. - Revilla I, Vivar-Quintana AM. 2008. Effect of canning process on texture of Faba beans (
Vicia Faba ).Food Chem. 106 : 310-314. - Tirado-Kulieva VA, Sanchez-Chero M, Villegasyarleque M, Aguilar GFV, Carrion-Barc G, Santa Cruz AGY,
et al . 2021. An overview on the use of response surface methodology to model and optimize extraction processes in the food industry.Curr. Res. Nutr. Food Sci. 9 : 745-754. - Sharafinia S, Farrokhnia A, Lemraski EG. 2022. Optimized safranin adsorption onto poly(vinylidene fluoride)-based nanofiber via response surface methodology.
Mater. Chem. Phys. 276 : 125407. - Yancheshmeh BS, Panahi Y, Allahdad Z, Abdolshahi A, Zamani Z. 2022. Optimization of ultrasound-assisted extraction of bioactive compounds from
Achillea kellalensis using response surface methodology.J. Appl. Res. Med. Aroma. Plants 28 : 100355. - Said KAM, Amin MAM. 2015. Overview on the response surface methodology (RSM) in extraction processes.
J. Appl. Sci. Process Eng. 2 : 8-17. - Isengard HD. 2001. Water content, one of the most important properties of food.
Food Control 12 : 395-400. - Ulloa JA, Enriquez Lopez KV, Contreras Morales YB, Rosas Ulloa P, Ramírez Ramírez JC, Ulloa Rangel BE. 2015. Effect of ultrasound treatment on the hydration kinetics and cooking times of dry beans (
Phaseolus vulgaris ).Cyta-J. Food 13 : 588-596. - Mathlouthi M. 2001. Water content, water activity, water structure and the stability of foodstuffs.
Food Control 12 : 409-417. - Mothibe KJ, Zhang M, Mujumdar AS, Wang YC, Cheng XF. 2014. Effects of ultrasound and microwave pretreatments of apple before spouted bed drying on rate of dehydration and physical properties.
Dry Technol. 32 : 1848-1856. - Li P, Li Y, Wang L, Zhang H, Qi XG, Qian HF. 2020. Study on water absorption kinetics of black beans during soaking.
J. Food Eng. 283 : 110030. - Miano AC, Sabadoti VD, Augusto PED. 2018. Enhancing the hydration process of common beans by ultrasound and high temperatures: Impact on cooking and thermodynamic properties.
J. Food Eng. 225 : 53-61.